BOOK: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
This book is critic-proof.
Even if the damning truth was that Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows was the biggest disappointment this side of Spider-Man 3, it would make not a jot of difference. Already, the seventh instalment of the boy wizard’s adventures has become the fastest-selling book of all time. This review is almost virtually redundant because chances are, you’ve read it already or worse, someone told you what happens in those final few pages.
Harry’s legion of fans had every right to be slightly concerned. 2003’s Order of the Phoenix was a bloated mess, in desperate need of an editor not so fixated on her publisher’s profit margins. The general view in Hollywood was that no-one was going to need to fret over what to cut for the cinematic outing, virtually the whole book could go because scarcely anything actually happens outside of a major character’s death. After such a crushing return following a three year hiatus (the previous four Potter books were released in a rather rapid annual succession), surely Rowling wasn’t about to ruin all that carefully laid groundwork?
In retrospect, Order was a canny move. It remains as frustratingly poor as it was four years ago but it marked a sea change in Rowling’s writing. Gone was the wild-eyed innocence of the first wave, in came a far darker central protagonist, now a brooding adolescent with little respect for authority. As ham-fisted in terms of structure book five was, Rowling was ultimately road-testing her prose and getting her audience used to the sharp shift away from stand-alone books seeded in a subtle fashion with future narrative towards the conclusion of a sprawling epic which would force a re-evaluation of those earlier efforts in lieu of new information.
Lucky then, that The Deathly Hallows finishes the Potter series with a flourish. It is perhaps the most radical of the seven; Hogwarts is barely seen until the action-packed, free-wheeling fight to the finish, and the focus is on Harry, Ron and Hermione like never before at the expense of the vast cast. Inevitably, your favourite is in there but glanced almost fleetingly. In that sense, Deathly Hallows also feels like a fond farewell, something that becomes obvious early on. Thankfully Rowling avoids turning Potter’s swansong into a greatest hits compilation.
However, the book is not perfect. There’s still a worrying amount of superfluous material and Rowling haphazardly advances time swiftly. Much of the middle chunk of this weighty tome is spent with Harry and friends on the run from the Death Eaters but there’s no sense of urgency. After the giddy glee of those first few chapters, much of the momentum feels lost and only a few key set pieces salvage what is otherwise a rather dry patch. Before Rowling knows it, she has to wrap it all up and so what follows is a motherlode of exposition which will be satisfying only once to those gagging to know everything while leaving everyone else quite exhausted.
Bearing that in mind, though, Rowling is a smart author. It’s obvious there’s always been a plan for her cast and she has wisely chosen to write for a growing audience, rather than taking the George Lucas approach and aiming at the same demographic all along. The Deathly Hallows is also undoubtedly the most cinematic of the set, taking some of its cues from the earlier films. On this evidence, it will be a rather exhilarating movie full of duelling wizards having been afforded the luxury of being able to slice much of the middle out.
How does it end? The only way it could. There is a short coda, which neatly puts a bow on that treat you’ve been waiting so very long for. By finishing with such a flourish (and it could easily have come across as clumsy) Rowling ensures that our only memories are fond ones and after all that effort, that no one comes away feeling cheated is a real accomplishment.
If you were going to buy this, you surely would have done by now. On the off chance that you haven’t though, click here.
As for this generation, the style that seems to have caught the current generation of young vibrant wannabes appears to be ‘Nu-Rave’, where new-wave and electronic noise is merged together to create a three minute record. One of the more recent, and probably one of the bands pushing the genre to the masses, are the New Young Pony Club, whose debut album Fantastic Playroom landed on the doormat this week.
Quite how readers managed to stay interested in this series on a week-by-week basis is staggering. Even as a collection of the first 13 weeks, Volume 1 is initially a lumbering collection of plot strands with very few redeeming features. It is a struggle to maintain interest with the fleeting storylines and unfamiliar characters. However, persevere, and a complex interweaving story begins to unravel and draw the reader in. Yes, it’d perhaps be easier to get into with background knowledge about the characters, but are there any books, comics, movies or TV series where that isn’t the case?
Like all good ideas, it started out so well. With a pedigree on television that included the acclaimed West Wing and Sports Night, the anticipation surrounding writer Aaron Sorkin’s latest project, a backstage drama about a live, Saturday night sketch show (comparisons with NBC’s long-running Saturday Night Live are entirely justified) reached a fever pitch. Collaborating with long-time Sorkin alums such as producer Thomas Schlamme, Bradley Whitford, Matthew Perry and Timothy Busfield, expectations were so high that American networks NBC and CBS entered into a bidding war that saw Studio 60 On The Sunset Strip head to the latter for a vast sum of money that was not only virtually unheard but guaranteed that there would be an unhealthy interest in the level of success the show would achieve.
As the series progresses, it becomes clear that there is only so much drama that can be wrung from Studio 60’s chief catalyst (‘the show’) and Sorkin decides to enliven proceedings by shifting the focus away from the production and towards the inter-personal relationships between the cast members, inventing increasingly outlandish and supposedly comedic sub-plots to drive the hour along. The seeds for this are sown midway through the first half of the season, and by the time Studio 60 reaches its twelfth episode all bets are off. What was previously a fizzing beacon of quality television has become an insidious melodrama full of haphazard romance and very little of what made the previous eleven episodes so electric.
Autobiographies are usually rubbish. Biographies aren’t too bad, as they generally show both sides of their character, but autobiographies only focus on the good character traits of people, and tend to avoid mentioning the little things like their drug-fuelled trips to Uganda or the ‘hilarious’ illegitimate children. Luckily, this book is different.