Review: Star Wars Episode I – The Phantom Menace 3D

Written by: David Lillywhite


The Phantom Menace is back. In 3D. David Lillywhite watched it so you don’t have to.

Anakin Skywalker casts the shadow of Darth Vader

Full disclosure: George Lucas did not “violate my childhood”.

I don’t care that Jar Jar Binks makes the Ewoks look like fucking Shaft. To me, the Star Wars films have always been highly effective B-movies – no more, no less – though I do prefer it when Greedo shoots first. Oh and yes, I was in the queue on day one for The Phantom Menace because I hoped, like most of us did, that it would be the start of something special. And it wasn’t. And it still isn’t.

Let’s be clear: time has not been kind to this film. Universally panned on release as one man’s enormously over-hyped act of self-indulgence, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace (incidentally, Lucasfilm, if you think I’m ever going to append that enormous prefix to every instalment of the hexology, you’re very much mistaken) is and remains a confused mass of special effects and bastard ret-conning. This is not a film that demands eloquent journalism, it should anger anyone that even has a passing interest in cinema. Movie as toy commercial. It’s been done before and it will be done again but to such stratospheric heights of clunking bland? Probably not.

If lightsabers and intergalactic space-fights are your thing (and let’s face it, that’s what we really wanted to see), there are a few rewards. Ewan McGregor channels Alec McGuinness almost too well and the Duel of the Fates set-piece that is the only interesting thing about the climax is still thoroughly entertaining but not worth slogging through 120 minutes of blissful temptation every time you hear that familiar ‘schwummb’.

The argument at the time was that adults just didn’t get it. Lucas had aimed the original trilogy ostensibly at children and of course he was going to continue in that vein. Except, The Phantom Menace is so deadly dull and dumb that only an embryonic foetus will have any trouble with it.

A lightsaber fight in Star Wars Episode I - The Phantom Menace

There’s just no editorial remit, no producer willing to take a stand. Lucas is so determined to jump-start one of cinema’s most enduring space sagas with a tale of galactic politics gone awry that he forgets the most important thing about these movies – character. In painting such broad strokes on such an artificial canvas it’s hard to engage with any of the cast save the ones you know are going to mean something later down the line.

And on that note, for anyone with even a passing interest in the Star Wars saga, it’s hard to get your head around the mammoth shift in storytelling emphasis that Lucas seeks to impose on his audience. It’s no longer Luke Skywalker’s journey, it’s supposedly Darth Vader’s story. It’s always been Darth Vader’s story. Much was made of the big tapestry being spun with the prequels but décor and costume nods aside (leading to plenty of knowing ‘I see where that’s going’ comments in the foyer), The Phantom Menace so flagrantly ignores the adage that a little mystery goes a long way, that the script’s determined additions to the accepted mythos just tear the heart of the story (midi-chlorians I’m looking at you). Star Wars never really needed to explain Vader’s genesis, it was enough to hint at the trauma in his life.

If 3D doesn’t actively serve and enhance the story, it’s just a tricksy gimmick, a sloppy crutch that makes everyone feel stupid, even in a darkened auditorium.

And what about the much-vaunted 3D conversion? In this instance, the workmen can blame their materials. Hollywood has already shown that for the most part, it doesn’t get 3D (unless your surname is Cameron or Scorsese). This wickedcool new technique is anything but and is usually employed either as a big fat rescue of a rather substandard film (surely all future Lindsay Lohan vehicles are bound for Direct-to-3DVD) or a somewhat cynical attempt to sell more tickets (or – in many cases – both). If it doesn’t actively serve and enhance the story, it’s just a tricksy gimmick, a sloppy crutch that makes everyone feel stupid, even in a darkened auditorium.

In the curious case of The Phantom Menace, no amount of money was ever going to make this distinctly flat film spring to life. None of those glossy effects – surely what might have been the saving grace, the intrinsic reason for paying to see this film again – ever truly pop. The 3D is underwhelming and scarcely noticeable but then, like so many other blockbusters, The Phantom Menace just wasn’t built with the future in mind. Ultimately it’s still the same critical Titanic it ever was only now you get to wear glasses while you watch it. The pod race is still an awkward visual spectacle that never really excites. If anything, the flaws are accentuated by the dashed expectation that the 3D process might have offered something new.

The pod race in Star Wars Episode I - The Phantom Menace

The real new hope of this re-issue is that someone works a miracle in time for the original trilogy. The Lucasfilm bucks can bank-roll Episodes II and III without any regard to likely box office and treats us all to the overhead Super Star Destroyer. Patient waiting: it feels like it’s 1999 all over again. But that must surely mean someone at Warner Brothers has thought about The Matrix.

Oh, and yes. The kids still love Jar Jar. Lucas definitely got that right.




Author: David Lillywhite

One of the founding writers for The Void, David has written as a critic and a columnist for a variety of publications all of which you have never heard of. Rescued from a life spent being generally terrified by the schlock-art of bottom-shelf VHS horror movies by editor savant Mike Shaw, David’s interests will come as no surprise to anyone who has observed the length of his sideburns: cinema, comedy, comics, ambient electronic music and new shiny tech. He keeps meaning to write a book. His favourite films are The Exorcist and Pleasantville and his preferred director is David Lynch.

Read more posts by


Responses to Review: Star Wars Episode I – The Phantom Menace 3D

  1. Scarface21No Gravatar

    Hilarious review. “The Phantom Menace is so deadly dull and dumb that only an embryonic foetus will have any trouble with it.” ROFL.

  2. You know I get that you don’t like the movie, but to express your hatred for it over and over again is unprofessional. While I’m not the biggest fan of the prequels, if you like any Star Wars movies, whether you admit it or not, every single one of them is fun. And if I’m wrong and you don’t find any of them fun, then why are you reviewing Star Wars in the first place?

  3. @DLCK “to express your hatred for it over and over again is unprofessional.”

    No it’s not, it’s opinion. Grow up, fanboy.

    “whether you admit it or not, every single one of them is fun”

    Not necessarily, it’s just a different opinion to you. Grow up, fanboy.

  4. Is the pic of anakin and the shadow of darth vadar worth any money?


Leave a comment